These homemade uncrustable sandwiches will solve all your back to school lunch packing problems. DIY uncrustables that you can make at home are easy to make ahead and perfect for school lunch.

Homemade Uncrustable Sandwiches

My kids love uncrustable sandwiches – I think all kids do! These easy to make sandwiches can be made at home and are a much more budget friendly and healthy crust free PBJ sandwich option.

More back to school breakfast and lunch ideas:

Where do I find the uncrustable tool?

You can find this handy tool here or you may even be able to find it at your local Walmart or Target.

Best Jelly for PBJ’s

Strawberry, grape, or raspberry are the classic most common flavors of jelly for peanut butter and jelly sandwiches. However you can use your favorite flavor of jelly or jam for these sandwiches.

Can I freeze homemade uncrustables?

Yes you can freeze these. When finished making the sandwiches just place them in baggies or freezer bags & store in the freezer.

Ingredients for Uncrustables

Sandwich press
Bread
Peanut Butter
Jelly – Grape, Strawberry, or whatever flavor your heart desires

How to make uncrustables at home

Begin by placing two slices of bread on the counter.

Then place a small scoop of peanut butter on each bread slice.

Next add a small scoop of your favorite jelly.

After that stack the bread together to make a traditional PBJ sandwich.

Now for the most important step take the sandwich press and place it on the sandwich. Simply press and turn to remove the crust and seal the sandwich.

Homemade Uncrustable

What You Need

Bread
Peanut Butter
Jelly

Directions

Begin by placing two slices of bread on the counter.
Then place a small scoop of peanut butter on each bread slice.
Next add a small scoop of your favorite jelly.
After that stack the bread together to make a traditional PBJ sandwich.
Now for the most important step take the sandwich press and place it on the sandwich. Simply press and turn to remove the crust and seal the sandwich.
Store in a sealed container or ziploc baggie.